"Franzen does not take his story very seriously, but the irony is indiscriminate and directionless; he hints at no frame of reference from which we are to judge his prose critically. Nor are we to imagine that a fool or semiliterate is addressing us. The same narrator who gives us “sucked” and “very into” also deploys compound adjectives, bursts of journalese, and long if syntactically crude sentences. An idiosyncratic mix? Far from it. We find the same insecure style on The Daily Show and in the blogosphere; we overhear it on the subway. It is the style of all who think highly enough of their own brains to worry about being thought “elitist,” not one of the gang."
“Jonathan Franzen’s juvenile prose creates a world in which nothing important can happen.” B. R. Myers’ review of Freedom, The Atlantic
meaghano said:
bs myers is an astounding shit bag but the voice in freedom IS off i think. if he just left it to “not working here” rather than One Should Never Do This Thing, he would have been okay.